Why Sizzze

Why "More Risk, More Reward" Misleads Investors

Contrary to popular belief, taking more risk doesn't guarantee more reward. The worst market days hurt far more than the best days help—and volatility often clusters.

By Dan Taren

Why 'More Risk, More Reward' Misleads Investors

📌 Key Insight:

Contrary to popular belief, taking more risk doesn't guarantee more reward. The worst market days hurt far more than the best days help—and volatility often clusters.

📉 Why More Risk Doesn’t Equal More Reward

Many investors assume that to earn higher returns, they need to accept greater risk. But this belief—while intuitive—doesn’t hold up well in practice. Losses hurt more than gains help, and in markets, the downside drags heavily on long-term returns.

📊 The Math of Missed Mayhem

Historical data reinforces this. From 1990 to 2020, the S&P 500 delivered a 9.3% annual return. But if you avoided just the 10 worst days over that same period, returns soared to 14.7%. That’s a 5.4 percentage point boost—without adding risk, just reducing exposure during downturns.

🚨 Risk Piles Up Fast

The worst days don’t arrive randomly—they cluster during market panics. So being risk-aware doesn't mean guessing tops and bottoms—it means protecting capital when fear spikes. Think of 2008, 2020, or early 2022. Timing exits around volatility can save years of compounding.

🔧 Tools for Smarter Timing

Using risk filters or volatility indicators can help guide exposure. Consider exiting risk assets when the VIX exceeds 30, or reducing stock holdings during prolonged drawdowns. These are tools—not predictions—that let investors manage risk in a repeatable way.

📈 Rewriting the Narrative

Instead of chasing returns by taking more risk, smart investors focus on smoothing the ride. Reducing exposure in turbulent times has consistently proven to enhance returns and reduce volatility. Don’t aim for risk—aim for resilience.

Schedule a call with Brandywine

Brandywine’s innovation of Risk Replacement is setting a new fiduciary standard for retirement plan advisors. We encourage you to use my calendar to set a time to learn more.

Select a Time